Random angst here. This will be stream of consciousness, a rant, unedited. Not to be taken internally. Consult your physician before using. Subject to change without notice.
We suck. Yeah, I said it.
This is a thread about the things that blow (in a bad way) in therapy/psychiatry. I've been doing this 23 years. I have a right to complain/critique. Am happy to critique my own stuff too if anybody is terribly concerned about it.
When I say "we", I mean the term loosely, and present company excepted. This means you.
Lemme (not to be confused with Lemmy, from Motorhead

...) give this some context. The Hippocratic Oath was apparently created around the 4th century BC (
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hippocratic_oath). Dude was considered the father of modern medicine. Since then, physicians have: cured the plague, figured out how to set and cast broken bones, can treat seizure disorders, have MRIs, fMRIs, made all kinds of improvements in preventative medicine (vaccines, handwashing and such), can put people under and perform surgery, have even come up with antibiotics- tooth decay being the primary thing that killed cro mangons ('sides Tyrannical Rexes or Tyrannical Bushes or whatever...).
Medicine has been curing and/or improving all kinds of "ills" in their discipline. Us, by comparison, have done little... even adjusted for the amount of time we've been around, if you exclude the likes of shamanism and spirituality and philosophy and such. We've not "cured" depression. Abuse, neglect, abandonment. We've not improved the way we communicate (don't even get me started on what we communicate
about. Schizophrenics rarely get better taken care of than when we were using Black 'n Decker "therapy" (AKA "trepanation"). Edison Medicine (ECT/electro convulsive therapy)? Are you kiddin' me? The Beck Depression Inventory? The MMPI? IQ tests? Major phail.
Look. Not saying there's not been improvements. Not saying there aren't beautiful examples of wisdom and progress. Maslow, Jung, Kopp, Buddha, all the Carls now that I think of 'em... medicines in some contexts/uses. All beautiful stuff.
That said though, here is my scream from the abyss. My laundry list of complaints that will only serve to subdivide me from my "peers".
1. In recent news, being present during "interrogations" (read: torture). At least finally 60% of us figured out how retarded that is. There's more reasons than can be recounted here.
2. Out of context use of medicines.
3. Use of medicines without insuring use of other types of therapies.
4. Diagnosing people that use drugs with various "mental illnesses" before they're even clean.
5. Us being e-motionally and/or spiritually sick when we come to the profession to begin with. We have a responsibility to be sane to begin with.
6. Speaking of: don't we have a responsibility to be more socially and polytrickally astute and forward-thinking than our counterparts in other disciplines?
7. Overuse of medications.
8. Overuse of diagnoses- particularly ADHD and BPDO.
9. Brief therapy, CBT, and other related therapies. Yeah, I said it. It's not that there's not useful tools there- on the contrary. What I struggle with is the context, it supplanting longer-term and arguably more relevant treatments, and what appears to be more a response to the behavior of insurance companies than it is a response to the behavior of patients.
10. Therapists and psychiatrists that can't handle feelings. Their own, or the patients'.
11. Misdiagnosing folk. Look- mood lability does not a bipolar person make
in and of itself. Same thing with "psychotic" symptoms. There's a whole laundry list of concomitant symptomatology, time factors and etc that allow us to diagnose someone.
12. Ignorance of biopsychosocial factors. We're so often looking at people as bundles of symptoms, and not really looking at folk (I know, groan of a word coming...)
holistically.
13. Lack of boundaries. If there's anything that makes us look cheap or lam3, this is it. Employing or sleeping with patients, bartering with fees, recovering addicts sponsoring patients in 12-step programs and the like. Phai1.
14. Oh 'god'. I almost forgot. Our interviewing skills? Horrid. Unbelievably bad. Embarrassing. They even transcend social skills- something I think we have a responsibility to possess in spades, no? Don't ask someone if they were "physically abused". By definition, it's the job of the patient to say "No." in most cases. Don't ask someone if they're a drug addict or alcoholic. I could write a whole book about how bad we are at this.
15. On the coattails of the above though, don't go for months, I've even seen clients who have been in therapy with someone else in excess of two years that though they described/behaved with many of the symptoms- have never been interviewed about abuse of any kind. No kidding. Massive phai1. Geez. If we're not here to dig in with people and their demons/psyches, WTF are we doing then?
K. That's enough. Use sparingly. Don't drink your own Kool Aid, and definitely, don't drink all of mine.